Decido, luego razono…

Ensayo sobre la arbitrariedad que se esconde detrás del caso CEPIS

Authors

  • Augusto Martinelli

Keywords:

public interest litigation, class actions, judicial discretion, arbitrariness

Abstract

This essay focuses on an unexplored aspect of the “CEPIS” case, in which the Supreme Court of Argentina nullified two administrative resolutions that ordered a substantial rate increase of the natural gas public service (2016). Particularly, it aims to demonstrate that the Supreme Court delivered a political solution for the conflict, not a legal one. To do so, the Court modified procedural and substantial aspects of the case. To demonstrate this, the essay will identify two changes imposed by the Court that totally modified the merits of the case. It will also identify a “false print in the way”, used to distract the Court´s auditoriums and make this ruling to be well-received by the public opinion. The final conclusion will assert how important is for the civil society to have efficient institutional tools to know when the discretional power of the judicature becomes arbitrary, against the Constitutional State.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Author Biography

Augusto Martinelli

Abogado patrocinante del Centro de Estudios para la Promoción de la Igualdad y la Solidaridad (CEPIS) en todas las Iinstancias judiciales. Auxiliar ad-honorem en Derecho Procesal Civil II, Cat. III Com. 7 Facultad de Ciencias Jurídicas y Sociales UNLP. El autor procuró evitar el uso de lenguaje sexista. No obstante, para facilitar la lectura no se incluirán recursos como la @. Es importante tener en cuenta esta aclaración para aquellos supuestos en los que no se haya podido evitar el uso del genérico masculino.

Published

2020-05-19

How to Cite

Martinelli, A. (2020). Decido, luego razono… : Ensayo sobre la arbitrariedad que se esconde detrás del caso CEPIS . Revista De Interés Público, (4). Retrieved from https://revistas.unlp.edu.ar/ReDIP/article/view/9956

Issue

Section

Artículos