Evaluation in science and technology in Argentina
Current situation and proposals
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24215/26183188e025Keywords:
Scientific evaluation, Scientific carrers, I D projects, Social actors, Scientific information systems, Anonimity, Blind peer review, ArgentinaAbstract
Evaluation is a fundamental part of the scientific and technological policy of a country and, given its performative character, is a tool that allows for the introduction of changes in the sector. In this paper we present a critique of the hegemonic paradigm of product evaluation, based mainly on quantitative indicators of papers and patents. Against this background we discuss the main issues of science and technology assessment in Argentina. Among them: the excessive amount there was the quantitative quantity; anonymity and lack of transparency; the primacy of ex ante evaluation is carried out exclusively by peers; the lack of coherence with policies and plans, and the undermining of evaluation systems. Finally, we present a series of proposals to improve the evaluation processes in the country, highlighting the need to achieve consistency with State policies and a National Science and Technology Plan, and to include non-academic actors in evaluation. of scientific-technological activity
Downloads
Metrics
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
The authors whose texts are published in this Journal surrender their ownership rights in favour of the editor in a non exclusive manner, i.e. the authors can enter into other independent and additional contracts to publish their text, e.g. including it in an institutional repository, thematic or otherwise, publish it in a book, or others, as long as it is overtly stated that the work was first published in this Journal.
The responsibility for each published paper as regards its content relies exclusively on its authors, holding the editors harmless for any legal liabilities.
The texts of the Journal shall be published under the Creative Commons 4.0 BY-NC-SA license. Therefore, the editors are free to:
1) Share, copy and redistribute the material using any means or format.
2) Adapt, remix, transform and create from the material, under the following conditions:
a) Attribution — credit to this work must be given in an appropriate manner, providing a link to the license and indicating if changes have been made.
b) Non-Commercial Use — no use may be made of the published material for commercial purposes.
c) Share Equal — Authors remixing, transforming or creating from the material must distribute their contribution under the same license as the original.